Proforma invoice vs commercial invoice: what exporters need to know
Proforma and commercial invoices look alike and many exporters mix them up. Yet they have different roles, different timing and different value. Confusing them can block customs clearance or a payment.
The full method, for any product: How to find international buyers for your export products: a 7-step method
The proforma invoice: an offer, before the sale
A proforma is issued before the sale. It shows the buyer what they will receive and pay. It is used to:
- confirm an offer precisely (product, quantity, price, Incoterm, delivery, payment);
- let the buyer open a letter of credit with their bank;
- obtain an import licence or permit in some countries;
- request a deposit.
It has no accounting value: it does not record a sale.
The commercial invoice: the document of the sale
The commercial invoice is issued at shipment. It records the sale and is used:
- by customs, at export and import, to assess duties and taxes;
- by the banks, in documentary collections and letters of credit;
- in your and the buyer’s accounts.
What each must include
| Item | Proforma | Commercial invoice |
|---|---|---|
| Seller and buyer (names, addresses) | Yes | Yes |
| Number and date | Yes (proforma number) | Yes (invoice number) |
| Precise description and HS code | Yes | Yes |
| Quantities, unit price, total, currency | Yes | Yes |
| Incoterm with place | Yes | Yes |
| Payment terms | Yes | Yes |
| Offer validity | Yes | No |
| Country of origin | Recommended | Yes |
| Weights, packages, transport references | If known | Yes |
Exact requirements depend on your country and the buyer’s: some customs authorities require specific statements on the invoice.
From proforma to invoice: a simple workflow
- Send the proforma once the buyer has agreed on product, quantity and price. State a validity date, for example 15 or 30 days, as prices and freight move.
- Wait for confirmation: signed proforma, purchase order, deposit or letter of credit opened on the basis of your proforma.
- Prepare the goods and the transport, then issue the commercial invoice with the actual quantities, weights and transport references.
- Check consistency between the invoice, packing list, bill of lading and, if any, the letter of credit before sending the documents.
If quantities change between the proforma and shipment, the commercial invoice must show what is actually shipped. With a letter of credit, check the tolerance it allows before shipping more or less.
Costly mistakes
- Sending a proforma instead of a commercial invoice for customs clearance: it is often rejected.
- Differences between proforma, invoice and letter of credit (amount, description, Incoterm): the bank may refuse the documents.
- Vague descriptions (“fruit”, “goods”): customs asks for details and the shipment is delayed.
- Missing currency or validity on the proforma, which invites disputes.
Frequently asked questions
Is a proforma invoice legally binding?
It commits you to the offer it describes, but it has no accounting value and does not record a sale. The commercial invoice does.
Can goods be cleared with a proforma invoice?
Sometimes for samples or shipments without payment, but for a sale customs expects a commercial invoice.
Do the proforma and the invoice need different numbers?
Yes. The commercial invoice follows your accounting numbering; the proforma has its own. Quoting the proforma number on the invoice is useful.
Must the proforma match the letter of credit?
The buyer opens the letter of credit from the proforma, so they should match, and the documents later presented to the bank must comply exactly with the credit’s terms.